Not quite Youngkin’s “macaca” moment, but close

[ad_1]

Republican Glenn Youngkin is joining the pantheon of Virginia governors who put their foot in their mouth, reducing themselves to punchlines.

Youngkin, campaigning last Friday for a congressional candidate in Northern Virginia, seemingly made light of the attack on Paul Pelosi, husband of U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, in the couple’s San Francisco home by a radicalized, hammer-wielding assailant whose intended target was the congresswoman.

Though Youngkin decried the violence — and might have stopped there — he continued: “We’re going to send her back to be with him in California.”


Schapiro: The Great Commonwealth Crack-up

Democrats were apoplectic, demanding Youngkin apologize for confounding horror as humor. Republicans went to ground, leaving it to Youngkin to defend himself, which he attempted in a hospitable setting: right-wing television.

People are also reading…

Questioned by Greta Van Susteren on Newsmax, Youngkin twice refused to apologize. Instead, he said that he doesn’t condone violence, adding that he and first lady Suzanne Youngkin are praying for Paul Pelosi’s recovery.

Queries about the faux pas to at least three operatives in Youngkin’s vast imaging operation went unanswered, affirming an important rule of crisis communications: Minimize further embarrassment through the strictest control of messaging.

That’s why Youngkin engaged a conservative media friendly whose national audience — Youngkin’s preferred audience, given his presidential ambitions — is less likely to think the worst of him and almost certain to believe mainstream news outlets are blowing his misstep out of proportion.

Though Youngkin — aided in his narrow 2021 victory by a titanic verbal goof by his Democratic opponent — said on Tuesday he “didn’t do a great job” expressing anguish over the attack, according to online Punchbowl News.


Schapiro: Youngkin’s by-the-numbers rant over student performance

In Donald Trump’s Republican Party — because his aberrant behavior is the standard for anyone with ambition — apologies are for wimps. An apology is a sign of weakness. It’s the cruelty that’s important, satiating voter resentments rooted in race, culture and class. Besides, an apology can extend the life of a story a politician would prefer die.

“Toddlers and politicians have something in common: their rewarded behavior is repeated behavior,” said Stephen Farnsworth of the University of Mary Washington, author of “Presidential Communication and Character: White House News Management from Clinton and Cable to Twitter and Trump.”

“A lot of Republicans have gained ground politically by being very combative. Youngkin is following suit…. This matter demonstrates that Youngkin is no longer portraying himself as a Virginia centrist. He’s now trying combativeness with 2024 in mind.”


Schapiro: Running for another office by running the one he has

Youngkin joins a rogue’s gallery of gaffe-gushing governors — Republicans and Democrats:

  • Ex-segregationist Mills Godwin, in 1981, attacks Democrats on racially charged issues, including statehood for heavily Black Washington, D.C., and, in 1985, criticizes Doug Wilder, a Black Democrat then running for lieutenant governor, for proposing the state song be junked because of its racially offensive lyrics. Democrats swept that year.
  • In 1991, Wilder, as the nation’s first elective Black governor and a presidential prospect, suggests Clarence Thomas, who had just been nominated for the U.S. Supreme Court, be pressed by senators for his stance on abortion because, as a Catholic, he has an “allegiance to the pope.” Denounced by Catholics, Wilder apologizes.
  • In 1994, George Allen, a Republican, rallies his party against Democrats in that year’s U.S. Senate race, declaring, “Let’s enjoy knocking their soft teeth down their whining throats.” Running for re-election to the Senate in 2006, Allen commits an epic boner, using a racial epithet — “macaca” — to describe an Indian American Democrat. It costs Allen a second term.
  • Gov. Jim Gilmore, a Republican, appropriates a phrase made famous by the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., declaring in 1999 Virginia “free at last, free at last” with the GOP taking total control of state government for the first time in more than century after the party installs a majority in the House of Delegates. Black Virginians brand Gilmore’s remark a sacrilege.
  • In 2016, U.S. Sen. Tom Kaine, a former governor and the Democratic nominee for vice president, out-Trumps Trump by frequently and rudely interrupting Republican Mike Pence during their televised debate at Longwood University. The performance augurs the only defeat, so far, of Kaine’s career.
  • Gov. Ralph Northam, a Democrat, bungles his response to the blackface calamity that nearly drove him from office in 2019. He compounds the humiliation by offering to perform a Michael Jackson-like moonwalk after disclosing he participated in a dance contest in the 1980s dressed as the performer — even smearing black shoe polish on his face.
  • Democrat Terry McAuliffe, running against Youngkin in 2021 for a second non-consecutive term as governor, blurts during a broadcast debate that parents have no place in the classroom. The blunder overnight becomes fodder for Youngkin, contributing to McAuliffe’s defeat to a political newcomer running on a parents’ rights plank.
  • (tncms-asset)b69bb708-4fc3-11ed-b47a-00163ec2aa77[3](/tncms-asset)

Except for McAuliffe and Allen, who tried and failed against Kaine in 2012 to avenge his Senate loss, all of these governors survived politically, though they were trivialized by their bombast and the tone-deafness, arrogance and ignorance that apparently contributed to it.

Former Lt. Gov. Bill Bolling, a Republican who briefly sought his party’s gubernatorial nomination in 2013, said our vitriolic politics demands that candidates and officeholders get it right the first time on whatever point they’re trying to make because “when you’re in the public spotlight 24/7, you don’t get any do-overs.”

Bolling, who teaches politics and policy at George Mason University, said apologies are impracticable because supporters believe they convey vulnerability and opponents consider them disingenuous: “It’s a no-win situation.”

Before his oops moment, Youngkin — having visited a dozen states as part of his continuing presidential audition — wasn’t breaking through with Republican primary voters. GOP polling firm Echelon Insights, in an Oct. 24-26 survey that had Trump and Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida at roughly 60% and 30%, respectively, put Youngkin and nine others at 0%.

Youngkin’s gaffe could be just the boost he needs.

Contact Jeff E. Schapiro at (804) 649-6814 or jschapiro@timesdispatch.com. Follow him on Facebook and Twitter, @RTDSchapiro. Listen to his analysis 7:45 a.m. and 5:45 p.m. Friday on Radio IQ, 89.7 FM in Richmond and 89.1 FM in Roanoke, and in Norfolk on WHRV, 89.5 FM.

[ad_2]

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *